[PtR] 博彩合法化对当今体育版图的影响

By Eric.Fritts | Pounding The Rock (PtR), 2025-08-04 23:00:00

由生成式 AI 翻译,译文内容可能不准确或不完整,以原文为准。

NBA: Chicago Bulls at Toronto Raptors

深入探讨体育与博彩公司能否在没有利益冲突的情况下共存。

让我们把思绪拉回到大约20年前的体育媒体界。那时有SportsCenter、全国电视转播、人们订阅的报纸或杂志,甚至还有初具雏形的博客。其中有多少内容是关于博彩的呢?

答案是:微乎其微,甚至根本没有。体育博彩当时仅限于赌场或地下庄家。若非刻意寻找,大多数人甚至不会意识到它的存在。而今天,情况恰恰相反。体育博彩公司无处不在。它们用广告、赛场内的标识和实时赔率轰炸着转播节目,永无休止。它们甚至拥有一些地方体育电视网。就连体育界的全球领导者ESPN,也推出了自己的博彩平台——ESPN Bet。

如果这看起来已经失控,那是因为事实的确如此。问题层出不穷。要说明情况是如何失控的,首先必须了解体育博彩公司是如何盈利的。这与大多数人的想法并不相同。

或许有些反直觉,但博彩公司并非追求让庄家获利的投注。他们并非拥有一长串持续输钱的客户名单——好吧,他们确实有,但这只是他们整体策略的副作用。博彩公司希望在其业务账簿上,赢家和输家的数量能够旗鼓相当。

体育博彩公司关注的重点是在赔率线的两边获得平衡的投注量。对他们而言,这是一场关于体量的游戏。正因如此,随着更多投注的涌入,赔率线会发生变动。博彩公司希望达到平衡。如果投注严重偏向一方,他们就会调整赔率,让另一方的投注看起来更具吸引力。从那里开始,就变成了供求经济学的问题。

他们这么做,是因为他们会从每一笔投注中抽取一小部分,这被称为“抽水”(vig)。这就是为什么“平赔”的投注,其胜负盘赔率仍然是-110。这多出来的-10就是他们为平衡账目而抽取的份额。粗略地说,他们希望一笔投注的两边有等量的投注额,这样在支付给赢家和输家后,收支正好相抵为零,然后他们再将抽水收入囊中。这类似于某些股票经纪公司虽然号称“零佣金”,但实际上在报价中已经内含了每笔交易几美分的费用。

对这方面感兴趣的读者,杰夫·乌尔里希 (Geoff Ulrich) 在这里对这一切以及更多内容进行了精彩的解读。

这就是为什么你会看到这些网站和应用程序几乎没有准入门槛,并不断宣传注册账户即可获得的奖金和免费投注金。赢家、输家,都无所谓——博彩公司要的是体量。这也是为什么那些只想观看体育比赛的观众会被无休止的广告轰炸。例如,在任何一场篮球比赛期间:比赛可能在FanDuel体育电视网播出;赛场内会有成百上千个博彩广告(即便是在体育博彩尚未合法化的州);电视上,至少会有一家,甚至三四家不同的博彩公司投放广告;整个转播过程中还会显示实时赔率。

可以说,这种铺天盖地的持续性广告,加上极低的准入门槛,已经导致了更多的丑闻、更多的问题,并且从整体上改变了许多球迷看待比赛的方式——而且是朝着更坏的方向。关于球员因其表现影响了某些人的投注而在网上和赛场上受到骚扰甚至威胁的故事屡见不鲜。更令人担忧的是,两名篮球运动员(特里·罗齐尔 (Terry Rozier) 和马利克·比斯利 (Malik Beasley))目前正在接受调查,而另一名球员(琼泰·波特 (Jontay Porter))已经认罪,并因此被NBA终身禁赛。

然后是利益冲突问题。如前所述,博彩公司会移动赔率线以平衡投注量。但现在,他们通过其影响、拥有或被其拥有的媒体,掌握了更大的权力。

对于地方体育电视网来说,这体现在实时赔率和赞助环节上。同样,这可能只是在利益冲突的边缘试探,但并未完全越界。但真正应该引起警惕的是前文提到的ESPN Bet。

ESPN接受投注本身就应该是一个明显的危险信号,尤其是在我们了解了赔率会随投注量而变动的情况下。ESPN是体育界最大的风向标之一。它提供观点、发布新闻,并且无论球迷喜欢与否,它都能在很大程度上主导体育界的时代思潮以及人们看待和讨论体育的方式。需要澄清的是,目前尚无证据表明这种情况正在发生,但谁能保证ESPN不会利用其影响力来改变公众对任何特定叙事的看法?谁又能保证它不会利用其权力来动摇部分博彩公众的观点?

这意味着,作为一台强大的机器,ESPN潜在地拥有用其舆论导向来平衡其投注量的能力。SportsCenter节目已经有了提供投注建议的环节,那又有什么能阻止他们为了平衡自家平台的账目而提供倾向性建议呢?

例如,在维克托·文班亚马 (Victor Wembanyama) 的新秀赛季初期,曾有关于切特·霍姆格伦 (Chet Holmgren) 是年度最佳新秀早期热门人选的讨论。这在当时看来很荒谬,事后看来也同样荒谬。但如果当时ESPN之所以推动这一说法,或者至少是着重展示那些持此观点的评论员,是因为押注文班亚马的投注额过于庞大,而他们需要平衡自己的数据呢?

一旦这一点被指出,就很难不在各处看到这种可能性。无论ESPN是否真的在这样做,这种可感知的利益冲突本身就足以构成一个问题。这让人们对他们播出的每一个故事和每一档节目都打上了问号。需要明确的是,ESPN并非唯一有潜力这样做的机构,但他们是最明目张胆的例子。体育媒体中到处都有赞助商提供的投注建议环节,但没有谁像ESPN这样,在米老鼠这个巨大的保护伞下,同时拥有自己的博彩业务。

归根结底,这一切都揭示了一个问题:边界的缺失。我们正在经历的,可以被视为一场剧烈的“禁令废除”。与之相比,大麻禁令的废除过程则温和许多,它是在缓慢而谨慎的节奏下逐步放开限制,而非全面合法化。

另一方面,酒精禁令也曾被剧烈废除。当初促使第十八修正案通过的那些担忧依然存在,但在现实证明需要更多边界后,这些问题才被逐步缓解。各州的边界规定不尽相同,但大都旨在遏制饮酒的危险。最明显的例子包括禁止酒后驾车、酒吧必须在特定时间停止营业、未成年人不得饮酒或购酒等等。德克萨斯州甚至禁止酒类销售代表在酒吧兼职,因为这存在他们可能会推销自己产品的利益冲突。

体育博彩似乎鲜有这样的边界。它在每条广告的结尾都会附上“1-800-GAMBLER”的求助热线,对大学赛事的广告也有一些限制,但在大多数情况下,这俨然一片淘金热下的狂野西部。它无处不在,每个人都想在还能分到的时候从中分一杯羹。现在的担忧是,这辆雪球是否已经滚得太快、太大,以至于无法停下。

我们当然可以寄希望于不会有任何不当行为或丑闻发生。但鉴于该行业已然面临的种种状况,这种希望并未奏效。赌博或其他恶习本身并没有本质上的错误,但它们需要制衡机制来减轻潜在问题。面对多起丑闻调查、公然存在且不受约束的利益冲突以及球员收到的威胁,我们很难辩称一切尽在掌控之中。那种对问题视而不见,直到不得不处理时才着手的想法,并非真正的策略。

如果体育博彩要继续在其发源的“地下”之外存在,它就需要某种形式的指导方针。这可以是在国家层面设立一个更强有力的监督委员会,更严厉地处理球迷骚扰行为,和/或限制广告投放。必须采取行动,因为事情不能再这样发展下去了。

点击查看原文:The impact of legalized gambling on today’s sports landscape

The impact of legalized gambling on today’s sports landscape

NBA: Chicago Bulls at Toronto Raptors

A deeper look into if sports and sports books can coexist without conflicts of interest.

Imagine, for a moment, sports media roughly 20 years ago. SportsCenter, national broadcasts, bundles of paper people would have delivered to the houses called newspapers or magazines, and even blogs in their infancy. How much of that focused on gambling?

The answer is little to none. Gambling in sports was reserved for either casinos or underground bookmakers. At a glance, most wouldn’t even know it existed unless you were looking for it. Today, it’s the opposite. Sports books are everywhere. They bombard broadcasts with advertisements, in-arena signage, and live lines; it’s never-ending. They even own some local sports networks. The worldwide leader itself, ESPN, has its sportsbook, ESPN Bet.

If this seems like things are out of control, it’s because they are. The issues are not in short supply. To cover how things got out of hand, it’s important to cover how sports books make their money. It’s not as most would think.

Perhaps counterintuitively, books aren’t going after action that favors the house. They don’t have a long list of clients constantly losing money, well, they do, but that’s a side effect of their overall strategy. Books want just as many winners and losers in their book of business.

What sports books focus on is getting balanced action on both sides of the lines. For them, it’s a game of volume. It’s for this reason that lines will shift as more action comes in. Books want things to balance. If action is heavy on one side of the bet, they will shift their lines to make the other side of the wager look more appealing. From there, it’s supply and demand economics.

They do this because they take a little off the top of every bet, known as the vig. This is why a bet with “even” odds will still have a money line of -110. That -10 is their cut to balance their spreadsheets. Roughly, they want an equal amount of action on both sides of a bet so they balance out to zero after paying winners and losers and then keep their cut on top. This is similar to a stock brokerage that might have $0 commissions, but they are taking a few cents per trade built into their quotes.

For those interested further, Geoff Ulrich offers a great breakdown of all of this and more here.

This is why you see relatively no barrier to entry on these sites and apps, constantly advertising bonuses and free money to bet with upon activating an account. Winners, losers, it doesn’t matter–the books want volume. This is why those trying to consume the sports are bombarded with relentless ads. For instance, during any given basketball game: it might be broadcast on FanDuel Sports Network; the arena will have hundreds of sports book ads (even in a state without legalized sports gambling); on television, there will be at least one if not three or four different books advertising; and live lines will show throughout the broadcast.

Arguably, this overwhelming and constant advertising combined with a low barrier to entry has led to more scandals, more issues, and an overall change in how many fans view the gam and for the worse. There is no shortage of stories of players being harassed or even threatened online and at games for how they performed relative to someone’s bet. What’s more concerning, two basketball players (Terry Rozier, Malik Beasley) are currently under investigation, and another (Jontay Porter) has pleaded guilty, resulting in a lifetime NBA ban.

And then there are the conflicts of interest. As explained, books will move lines around in order to balance the action out. But now they have much more power in the form of the media they influence, own, or are owned by.

For local sports networks, this comes in the form of live lines and sponsored segments. Again, this might toe the line of conflicting interests but doesn’t outright cross it. What should be alarming is the aforementioned ESPN Bet.

ESPN taking bets should be an obvious red flag, especially knowing how lines will shift with the action. ESPN is one of the largest tastemakers in sports. It offers opinions, breaks news, and can largely dominate the zeitgeist of sports and how it’s perceived and discussed, whether fans like it or not. To be clear, there is no evidence of this happening as of yet, but who’s to say ESPN can’t use its influence to shift public perception of any given narrative? Who’s to say it can’t use its power to sway some of the betting public’s opinion?

What this means is that, being the machine that it is, ESPN potentially has the power to balance its action with its narratives. SportsCenter already has segments giving picks, what’s to stop them from offering picks that favor balancing their books?

For example, early on in Victor Wembanyama’s rookie season, there was discussion around Chet Holmgren as an early pick to win Rookie of the Year. It was ludicrous then, and it’s ludicrous in hindsight. But what if ESPN was pushing that narrative, or at least showcasing the pundits that thought that way, because the action of Wembanyama was so heavy and they needed to balance out their numbers?

Once it’s pointed out, it’s hard not to see this everywhere. Regardless of whether ESPN is doing this or not, the perceived conflict of interest is enough for it to be an issue. It puts into question every story and segment they have. And ESPN isn’t the only one with the potential to do this, to be clear, but they are the most egregious example. There are sponsored segments giving picks everywhere in sports media but no one actually owns their own book-making and has it all within one giant Mickey Mouse umbrella.

Ultimately, what this all sheds light on is the lack of boundaries. What we are experiencing is what could be looked at as a drastic repeal of prohibition. Compare this to the soft repeal of cannabis prohibition, which slowly and trepidatiously saw more allowances instead of widespread legalization.

Alcohol, on the other hand, was drastically repealed as well. And those same concerns that passed the 18th Amendment still existed, but were slowly mitigated after it was apparent it needed more boundaries. The boundaries differ from state to state, but are mostly all in effect to curb the dangers of drinking. The obvious ones are driving while intoxicated, bars have to stop serving at a certain time, minors aren’t allowed to consume or purchase, et cetera. Texas even forbids alcohol sales reps from working second jobs at bars because of the conflict of interest in that they might push their own products.

Sports betting appears to have very few of those boundaries. It has the 1-800-gambler at the end of every ad read, and some limitations on its advertising around college events, but for the most part, this is the wild west in a gold rush. It’s everywhere and everyone wants a piece of the pie while they can still get it. The concern now is if the ball is rolling too fast and has accumulated too much mass to stop.

It can be hoped that there won’t be any foul play or scandalous activity. But that hasn’t worked given the circumstances the industry already sits in. There isn’t anything inherently wrong with gambling or other vices, but they need checks and balances to mitigate potential issues. With several scandal investigations, glaringly unchecked conflicts of interest, and players receiving threats, it’s hard to argue things are under control. The idea of ignoring issues until they have to be dealt with isn’t a real strategy.

If sports betting is going to continue to exist outside of the underground it came from, it needs some sort of guide rails. That could come in the form of a stronger oversight committee at the national level, stronger enforcement of fan harassment, and/or limits on advertising. Something needs to be done because things can’t keep going the way they are.

By Eric.Fritts, via Pounding The Rock